Skip to content
All articles
FAQ 5 min read

FAQ: How to Interpret a Vendor's PVS Score and Pillar Breakdown

A plain-English guide to reading the five score pillars, understanding score tiers, and knowing when a score should raise a red flag.

PepAssure team

April 15, 2026

The Five Pillars at a Glance

Every vendor's PVS score averages the pillars that have data, then withholds half the weight of any pillar with no data. A missing pillar is not scored as 0, and two perfect lab pillars publish 80, not 100:

  • •Purity Testing (35%) — recency-weighted average of the independent lab results on file
  • •CoA Verification (25%) — how much independent documentation stands behind the vendor, weighted by who tested the sample
  • •Community Sentiment (18%) — approved reviews, Trustpilot stars, and qualifying X posts (Reddit mentions are shown, not scored)
  • •Vendor Transparency (14%) — a verified claim with real contact details; nothing else measured yet
  • •Order Experience (8%) — not measured yet; a placeholder on provisional scores

What Score Should I Look For?

90–100 · Top tier

Top-tier vendor. Consistent CoA documentation, high confirmed purity, strong community reputation, transparent practices. Safe choice for most research.

80–89 · Strong

Solid vendor with minor gaps. Might be missing a pillar or two — check which ones. Often a newer vendor building their documentation history.

70–79 · Acceptable

Acceptable but investigate further. Look at which pillar is dragging the score. A low CoA score here is a significant concern.

60–69 · Investigate

Meaningful concerns. We'd recommend checking the community sentiment and CoA sections carefully before ordering.

Below 60 · Red flags

Major red flags in at least one pillar. Not recommended without independent due diligence.

Common Misreadings

"High purity but low CoA score — should I trust the purity number?"

No. Purity is only as trustworthy as the documentation supporting it. A low CoA score means the documentation itself is questionable. A vendor can claim any purity percentage — the CoA pillar tells you whether we could verify it.

"Great community sentiment but low transparency — what does that mean?"

It usually means the vendor is popular but hard to reach or has incomplete information published. Worth a direct communication test before ordering.

"The score changed overnight. Is something wrong?"

Not necessarily. Nightly re-scoring incorporates newly indexed lab results, newly confirmed CoA uploads, and fresh reviews. A 1-2 point swing is normal. A sudden drop of 5+ points suggests a new negative signal — click through to the vendor's activity feed to see what changed.

Red Flags Worth Knowing

  • •Any single pillar below 50 is a significant concern, regardless of total PVS
  • •A CoA sub-score below 60 means we could not verify the quality documentation
  • •Vendors marked "Not yet scored" have no independent data on file — there is no score to read

Related Articles