Skip to content
All articles
Research 12 min read

Inside the PVS Scoring System: Our 5-Pillar Methodology

How the PepAssure Vendor Score is calculated — which lab results feed it, how vendor uploads are weighted, and what is not measured yet.

PepAssure team

April 2, 2026

Overview

The PepAssure Vendor Score (PVS) aggregates five weighted pillars into a single 0-100 number. This post is the short version; the methodology page lists every input, every cap and every weight, and is kept in step with the code.

The Five Pillars

1. Purity Testing (35%)

A recency-weighted average of the lab results on file for the vendor — nothing else:

  • •Results an independent lab published under its own name, which we index ourselves (Finnrick's per-peptide rating, Janoshik's purity figures) — full weight
  • •Reports a vendor uploaded from a lab on our recognized list, once a member of our team has read the purity off the document — half weight, and capped at 85 until a lab-published result exists
  • •Results tested in the last 90 days count 1.0, 91–180 days 0.5, older or undated 0.25

A certificate a vendor posts on its own storefront is shown but never scores. We do not run tests, and we do not read chromatograms or mass-spec data.

2. CoA Verification (25%)

The same lab rows, weighted by source: 70% Finnrick + 30% Janoshik when both exist; Janoshik alone capped at 85; verified vendor uploads add a 20% term on top, or stand alone capped at 85. We do not check lab accreditation, contact labs, or match documents against a reference library.

3. Community Sentiment (18%)

Approved PepAssure reviews (verified-purchase reviews count twice; reviews we seeded ourselves are excluded), Trustpilot stars on a profile we can match to the catalog, and X posts that name a catalog vendor. Ads on X are shown and do not score; closure, FDA, shipping, purity, CoA, and scam language counts double, and X is included only after three qualifying posts. The pillar stays blank until Purity or CoA already has data, so it can move a score and cannot create one. On a provisional score the same blend is averaged with a placeholder. We also read 14 peptide subreddits every six hours and label each mention with the same word list — that feed is shown on vendor pages but does not move the score. The Reddit collector does not record account age or karma, so there is no shill screen behind it.

4. Vendor Transparency (14%)

No measured input today. A vendor on a provisional score carries a fixed placeholder of 82 (completing a verified claim is itself the signal); every other vendor's pillar is blank.

5. Order Experience (8%)

No measured input today. A fixed placeholder of 80 on provisional scores; blank otherwise. Shipping, packaging and support are not measured.

Score Calculation

Each pillar with data produces a 0-100 sub-score. The PVS averages those scores on their published weights. A pillar with no data is left out, and half of its weight is still withheld:

PVS = ceil( average of measured pillars × (1 − 0.5 × missing weight) )
weights: Purity 0.35 · CoA 0.25 · Sentiment 0.18 · Transparency 0.14 · Experience 0.08

A blank pillar is never filled with an estimate. Purity 100 and CoA 100 with the other three blank publish 80, not 100. Risk penalties follow (−10 per lab result below 60, −5 per result from 60 to 69, −5 for a vendor founded less than a year ago), and the result is clamped to 0-100. A vendor with no scorable input on any pillar is shown as "Not yet scored".

Every vendor is re-scored nightly.

Score Tiers

  • •90-100: Exceptional — top-tier vendor with consistent quality
  • •80-89: Strong — reliable vendor with minor areas for improvement
  • •70-79: Average — acceptable but some concerns flagged
  • •60-69: Below Average — significant issues detected
  • •Below 60: Poor — major red flags, not recommended

Related Articles